Restaurants

Still Water Pizza & Grill

4.4 304 reviews Closed 45 N Main St, Wellsville, NY 14895, United States

Discover this place

Still Water Pizza & Grill, nestled in the heart of Wellsville, NY, has quickly earned a reputation as a must-visit eatery. Reviews highlight the standout service, particularly praising server Beth for her attentive and energetic approach. The menu offers a variety of hearty options, from delectable appetizers like Fried Cheese Curds and Coconut Shrimp to an inventive Mac & More section featuring creations like the Buffalo Mac and Stilly Philly Mac.

Burgers also shine here; patrons rave about the Mushroom Swiss Burger, noting its perfect cooking and generous portion sizes. One customer emphasized that it was among the best burgers they had ever tasted, highlighting its freshness and the appealing presentation.

Overall, diners appreciate the quick service and quality of food, with many dishes, such as the onion rings and house fries, earning commendations for taste and crispiness. With a clean environment and friendly atmosphere, Still Water Pizza & Grill stands out as a delightful dining destination in Wellsville, promising satisfaction on every plate.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Still Water Pizza & Grill before visiting.

Reviews for Still Water Pizza & Grill

4.4

304 reviews

100%

33%

Review highlights

Based on 304 reviews

Still Water Pizza & Grill in Wellsville, NY, consistently receives praise for its high-quality, flavorful burgers and well-prepared sides like onion rings and fries. Reviewers commonly highlight the freshness and careful cooking of their hand-pressed burgers, noting good portion sizes and satisfying meals. The restaurant environment is described as clean and friendly, with staff responsiveness varying; some employees receive commendations for attentiveness and efficiency, while others are noted as less engaged. Wait times are generally short, and overall, the establishment is appreciated for providing a welcoming atmosphere and reliably good food that appeals to local patrons and visitors alike.

Kellie Graves

Sep 15, 2025

Very satisfied with your server Beth. She's always busy, never standing around. Made our experience here very enjoyable. Of course great food! Sad to see some of the other employees just standing around. Overall, ask for Beth Employee of the year!

Tonia Spencer

Jul 28, 2025

My son tried there. Jalapeno burger and it was great.. and I had their bacon double cheese and it was so filling.I could not finish it.. Delicious their onion rings and their front fries were also phenomenal

Jul 16, 2025

I ordered a mushroom swiss burger. It was cooked to perfection. I have had burgers in other places statewide. This was one of the best that I have ever had. The burger was not overcooked, undercooked, greasy, or lacked meat. They had a brand new cook there and I must say the presentation of the meal, including the meal itself, was great!! The place was clean and friendly. Thank you very much for your service.!! Yummy !

Brandon Whittemore

Jul 11, 2025

For a small eatery, I must give it 5 out of 5 for the awesome mushroom swish burger. Maybe 10 min wait, fries were hot. The burger was hand pressed which is an oddity today. And they did not charge extra for the grilled onions.

rob ford

Jul 07, 2025

Food comes pretty fast now since they’ve opened. Everything we’ve ordered has been good.

Michelle Leitten

Jun 29, 2025

We have been here 4 times in the past two months and have been super impressed each time. The chicken sandwich tastes very fresh and is cooked perfectly. The harvest salad is loaded with toppings and is big enough for two people. I am fussy about my G&T and each time the bartender made it perfectly and the server showed patience and kindness. Also to note, the owner has been on the premises each occasion which included weekend and weeknights. The outdoor seating is a plus and the restaurant seemed very clean. My ONLY comment was that the outdoor music was a tad loud, but I am old and I asked if they would consider lowering the volume and they did, so thanks so much.

Jason Hamilton

Jun 28, 2025

Stillwater is an absolute gem! I've been here a few times and have yet to be disappointed. The food is fantastic—I've tried a bunch of different items on the menu, and each one has been delicious. The staff is always on their A-game, super friendly, and incredibly attentive without being overbearing. Plus, if you're a sports fan, the atmosphere is perfect for catching a game. Highly recommend!